
Okay, so I know most readers of Esquire (except me) are probably not comedy sophisticates, but my first impression reading their list of "up and coming" comedians was "Are you f**king kidding me, Esquire?"
This thing is so offensive to the comedy fan that I have no choice but to do a line-by-line analysis.
First, the premise: "Will the Next Dane Cook Please Stand Up?" Nothing against Dane Cook, who has worked hard to gain exactly the success he has, but it's a bit insulting to assume every comedian has a career goal of starring in Jessica Simpson movies. And then they go on to insult Dane Cook anyway! So why do they want "the next" one? (Answer: they needed an easy angle for their story)
Next, this jaw-dropper, italics mine:
"While many now think Cook's Burger King-based comedic stylings are
shit, that shit has provided the fertilizer for a bumper crop of
brilliant new-alt comics, all of whom are launching careers the same
way Cook did — using the Internet and bubbling up from the
underground."
Um, excuse me? Are you actually saying that David Cross, who any comedy fan recognizes as one of the most influential comedians of his generation (the most influential TV show: Mr. Show with Bob and David), is "launching a career" on the back of Dane Cook? I want to punch something.
Now, Their List:
1. "David Cross: The Front Runner"
Yeah, no f**king sh*t. See above.
2. "Aziz Ansari: The Internet Sensation"
I'll give them this one on the "Esquire readers might appreciate discovering Aziz while looking for new ways of tying $250 ties or whatever" curve. But his success has nothing to do with Dane Cook.
3. "Demetri Martin: The Straight Man"
Yeah. Also: "Demetri Martin: The Comedian We Get Fan Letters About From Actual Grandmas in Nursing Homes". Also, uh, Reader's Digest scooped you back in January. That has to hurt.
4. Flight of the Conchords: The Musical Duo
Nice!! It's only the most talked about show of the summer. Also, your prediction: "What’s next: Becoming the next Tenacious D, one raunchy sex song at a time." The next Tenacious D, you say? Oh, you mean the same Tenacious D that the aforementioned David Cross helped discover and produce? Just checking!
5. "Patton Oswalt: The Best Part of Anything He's In"
Spit take! Now I'm starting to think this list is intended to cause heart attacks. While Patton Oswalt is indeed the best part of anything he's in, if you're old enough to read Esquire and have not yet heard of Patton Oswalt, you are probably not now nor will ever be a comedy fan. Your disclosure: "(And also, he's written for Esquire)" And I'm sure he'll be dying to again now that you've suggested that his entire career grew up from the fertilizer of Dane Cook's shit!
6. "Ben Gleib: The Hidden Camera Guy"
Okay, you got me: I've never heard of this guy. But judging from your description:
You know him 'cause: He was the only funny part of The Real Wedding Crashers
His funniest bit involves…: Calling a random audience member out for a gaudy piece of clothing – and then biting on him for the entirety of his set.
I gather that 1. you watch The Real Wedding Crashers and 2. You have never seen a live comedy show other than this guy's because that's called "crowd work" and is most often (though not always) associated with hacks.
Which, when I think about it, means at least 1/6th of this list could be correct. Thanks, Esquire! I'll look for this last dude in the next Jessica Simpson vehicle!
Later this week: I'll give you OUR list of up and coming comedians. (And maybe I'll throw in some incorrect instructions for tying a Windsor knot just to make things even.)
UPDATE: Leave your suggestions in the comments!